Church of Our Savior v. City of Jacksonville Beach
Share this Case
The Church of Our Savior, an Anglican congregation in Jacksonville Beach, Florida, is now free to begin construction on a new, permanent house of worship for its growing congregation.
A small church in an even smaller building
In 2013, Resurrection Anglican Church joined with another Anglican church in Jacksonville Beach, Florida, to form the Church of Our Savior. Since its founding, the Church has worshipped in six different facilities. Most recently, the congregation has met and worshipped in the historic Beaches Museum Chapel. The Church leased the Chapel for Sunday worship, as well as major holiday celebrations, weddings and Bible studies.
Yet the Chapel was a less than ideal home. The facility’s maximum capacity of 140 people forced the Church to split into two separate Sunday services, which limited the Church’s growth and inhibited its ability to perform sacraments and worship in one unified celebration. To make matters worse, the congregation could not secure a long-term lease with the Chapel, and therefore had no permanent place to worship.
The search for a new home
Reverend David Ball, pastor of the Church of Our Savior, had long dreamed of one day building and owning a permanent home for the Church. He searched throughout Jacksonville Beach, located 140 miles north of Orlando, for a property that was affordable, visible, and accessible. After years of searching, he finally found a property located in a beautiful residential area that was all three.
Hopeful in its prospects, the Church applied for a permit to be able to construct the new facility. But its permit application was twice denied.
Becket defends the Church of Our Savior
The Church of Our Savior filed suit, citing a federal civil-rights law that protects churches — the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA) — and arguing that it had been treated unequally to other similar, nonreligious organizations seeking permits. Becket, along with attorneys Dan Dalton of Dalton & Tomich and Charles Stambaugh of Stambaugh & Associates, defended the Church of Our Savior in its fight for a new, permanent house for worship.
After a federal district court found in the Church’s favor in the fall of 2014, the Church and the City settled the case on terms allowing the Church to begin construction on its new home, which will begin in 2016.